I haven’t rated the i4 yet. It’s the last of a line-up BMW cut back to one variant, the eDrive35, and the Geely EX5 is the value leader in this class. Here’s what the reviewers found.
What you’re getting
A rear-drive liftback on the 4 Series Gran Coupe platform, with a single motor and a 66.4kWh battery. Drive and carsales both say it rides well on the standard 18-inch wheels, and Drive warns off the bigger wheels. carsales and Drive also note it sits under the luxury car tax threshold, which keeps it exempt from fringe benefits tax. CarsGuide and Drive like the physical switchgear and the rotary iDrive controller. The liftback boot is easy to load, and Drive points out you can get a child seat in over the headrests like an SUV. A 10 to 80% charge takes 32 minutes.
What’s wrong with it
The back seat comes first. CarExpert, carsales, CarsGuide and Drive all say adults are cramped: tight headroom under the roofline, a tall floor hump left over from the petrol platform, and short rear doors that make getting in awkward.
Range is next. The claim is 448km, but CarExpert saw around 370km in real driving. CarsGuide found urban consumption worse than claimed, while Drive matched the claim. CarExpert, carsales and CarsGuide all put the i4 behind the Model 3 on range, and CarExpert and CarsGuide add the Polestar 4 and Polestar 2 in the same breath.
Then the screens. CarExpert, carsales and Drive all say climate and other basic controls are buried in menus. CarExpert found the dash and door cards scratchy black plastic and several fittings hollow, and Drive heard a creak when turning or backing out of a driveway. CarsGuide notes there’s no active lane-centring. CarsGuide also counts the five-year warranty against rivals offering seven or more.
There’s no frunk and no spare wheel, only a can of goo (carsales).
Living with it
Nothing yet from owners, and nothing on how it holds up past a year.
Before I rate it
- What does it do better than a Chinese EV or a Tesla Model Y?
- Does anything about it justify its place in the class against the EX5, or against the Model 3, which CarExpert, carsales and CarsGuide all list as the cheaper car with more range?
- Is it doing something different, as four-wheel steering would be, or is it a combustion-car platform with a battery in it?