Everything on this site comes out of a few positions. They’re different enough from how cars are usually written about that they’re worth stating up front.
Cars don’t matter as much as you think
Most decent modern cars are all much the same, and they’re all a bit boring.
That’s not cynicism, it’s progress. The differences that used to matter got engineered away. What’s left is largely taste and marketing.
What a car is for
Getting you and yours from A to B, reliably, at a sane price, in decent comfort.
That’s the whole job. Everything a car does beyond it is extra, and extra is fine — I like a nice thing as much as anyone — but it should be priced and judged by what those extras are worth to you. So when I rate a car, that’s the test. Not how it feels to a reviewer who has it for a week. How it’ll feel on a Tuesday in year four.
Money matters
This is the part car media gets wrong, and it’s not close.
Middle-class incomes everywhere are stretched. Mortgage, childcare, insurance, power, groceries — all of them going up more than your paycheck. The household that looks comfortable on paper is often running very little slack.
Into that walks a salesperson with the most effective line in the business: it’s only thirty dollars a week more.
Thirty dollars a week is fifteen hundred a year. Over a five-year term that’s seven and a half thousand dollars, for a difference you will have stopped noticing by the second month. The framing is designed to make a large number feel small. Don’t let it.
If the thirty-two thousand dollar car is genuinely good, don’t pay thirty-eight for one that’s just as good — unless you can clearly articulate, to yourself, what the extra six thousand buys you.
Often the more expensive car isn’t even better. Sometimes it’s slightly worse. Very often it’s just different — the same car with different choices made, marketed as an upgrade. Same but different is not worth six thousand dollars.
Take the BYD Atto 2 at $31,990 and the BYD Atto 3 at $46,990. They’re so similar that most people can save the money and buy the Atto 2.
A good car can be a bad purchase
Imagine someone built an exact Model Y clone. Same car, same everything, ten thousand dollars more. Is it a good car? Yes — it’s a Model Y. Is it a good purchase? Absolutely not. Why would you pay ten thousand dollars more for the same thing?
That’s the distinction almost every review misses. They tell you whether a car is good. I’m telling you whether buying it is smart, and the answer depends entirely on what else you could have for the money. A car’s value isn’t a property of the car. It’s a relationship between the car and everything else on sale at that price.
Why price is the variable now
The old advice — spend more, get a better car — used to be true. It mostly isn’t now.
Engines don’t shake. Suspension doesn’t crash. Seats don’t wreck your back. The base model got good, and the expensive version increasingly sells materials, badge and options rather than capability. Electric cars accelerate the trend, because the drivetrain that used to separate cheap from expensive is now a motor and a battery, and the cheap one is quick.
Which means the sensible move today is close to the opposite of the received wisdom: buy the good cheap thing, and put the difference somewhere it matters.
Nothing explodes
In ICE engines you have explosions. So things vibrated and shook. So you had a clear hierarchy of cars — the Lexus engine was amazing, Range Rover did a good job insulating the passengers from the explosions. You could see why you would pay more.
Along came the EV and upended all that. Nothing explodes. The motor just turns. There are no vibrations coming from the car itself. So now a cheap EV like a BYD Atto 1 is more silent and vibrates less than the most expensive Rolls-Royce ever built before they switched to batteries. In fact, any cheap Chinese EV has more technology than the most expensive European car ever built — well, pretty much; just look at the screen, the systems, the buttons.
Now, expensive EVs still have quality-of-life things — better materials, tyres, acoustic glass. So an Atto 1 will have more road noise than an expensive EV. But it’s already a leapfrog from an ICE. Past a good modern EV, we’re grasping at straws.
The battery is the chassis
Another thing I spent a lot of time and money on — doubling up chassis, extra metal plates at critical points. Today, with an EV, the battery frame gives you a more solid chassis out of the box than what all ICE makers were dreaming of for decades.
Tech is table stakes
iPhones have lightning-fast chips. Outside of self-driving, they can power a car easily. So all this talk about tech is overblown for cars.
Tech is becoming table stakes. So what exactly are the expensive brands spending money on?
I would pay extra for tech. I once paid 3x for a better turbo to fit into a rally car, because it was 20% better than the 1x turbo. In rally driving we paid approximately 8x for a better helmet — to save your noggin, any better is worth a lot of money. I understand paying more for the better thing. But I’m really struggling to see what is usefully better in some of these expensive cars.
The family SUV, against the family EV
The Corolla Cross test
I drove the Corolla Cross hybrid extensively recently, the brand new model. It’s a nice car, but it is dated. It’s a little bit cramped, and the boot is sort of smallish. They took a car and made a mini SUV outfit, and overall it just felt dated after sitting in an EV. The engine and the transmission take up a bit of space, which you feel sitting inside the car. It’s designed on a really tight budget: a budget engine, a budget transmission, really a budget everything.1
Now compare a $40,000 car with a $30,000 EV. Test drive a Corolla Cross hybrid against really any EV up to ten thousand dollars cheaper: any which way, the EV feels technologically smarter, more able. The screens are bigger, the seats are better. The Chinese companies are thinking more about this. At the same price, a Geely EX5 is so much nicer.2
So at $45k for the hybrid, I can get a better EV for $30k, and if I pay $42k for a Geely EX5, it’s heaps better.
For a family, the car to look at is the BYD Atto 2. With kids, slightly taller is good. It helps to have a bit more storage and to be able to easily put in car seats.3 Any other EV around $40k is an upgrade on the Atto 2, in specs and probably in feel.4
And the price could come down further thanks to the FBT exemption, which continues for now.
A petrol car’s resale value
A warning on all of these basic petrol cars: keep in mind their value is going to plunge. These are literal dinosaurs. Even brand new, a Corolla Cross or a Mazda CX-5 is in so many ways inferior to the equivalently priced EV, so used prices are going to fall a lot, because no one will want your Toyota. Three years later, you’re facing a pretty steep decline.5 EVs will lose value too, because the technology is improving, but I don’t think as fast as some people think. People understand these cars like buying a toaster. If you can charge at home, you’re pretty much golden.6
How big a car you need
Size is the one honest cost
What makes a car? Materials. So size means it has more stuff. So size does correspond to something. And with EVs we see it more clearly.
Buy for the 51 weeks, hire for the 1
I used to camp seriously. Remote, self-sufficient, the sort of trip where reliability and capability matter and you plan around them. I don’t do that now. Occasionally, or with a friend who’s still set up for it.
If I’d bought a vehicle for the version of me that did that, I’d still be driving it — paying for capability I stopped using years ago, every day, on the school run.
That’s the trap. People buy for the life they had, or the life they picture, rather than the one they’re living. Not everyone can borrow a mate’s setup for the rare trip, so this is a personal calculation. But it is a calculation, and most people never do it.
You can camp almost anywhere in this country in a normal SUV. Australian roads are good — sealed, maintained, signposted. I’ve driven in places where the road has simply stopped existing, and this isn’t that. Most of the destinations people buy a giant four-wheel drive to reach are reachable in something ordinary and considerably cheaper.
Don’t underestimate what a basic car can do. And for the once-a-year trip that needs more, hire the thing. It’ll cost you a fraction of owning the wrong car for the other fifty-one weeks.
The baby doesn’t need a truck
There’s a belief in this country that a child requires an enormous vehicle. It doesn’t.
Cars have grown steadily for decades. Today’s ordinary family car is bigger than the large car of twenty years ago. If you’re buying a modern five-star-rated car, your child is in a safe vehicle — you don’t need to upgrade to something the size of a small truck.7
You’ll hear the anecdotes. We had a crash in the Land Cruiser and my kid walked away. Those go in the bin marked anecdotes. Yes, in some collisions a heavier vehicle is better for the people inside it — and worse for everyone outside it, and worse again if you roll it. But for ordinary suburban life, a car you’re happy to drive and can actually park beats sheer size, every time.
And there’s a cost nobody counts. If stretching for the bigger car means cheaper groceries or the piano lessons don’t happen, you’ve made your child’s life worse to buy a feeling of safety. Spend the money on things that matter.
Seven seats, wrong shape
Before you buy a seven-seat electric SUV, look at a seven-seat people-mover. They’re about the same size and about the same money, and they’re better at the job in just about every way that matters once the kids are in the back — more usable third row, easier access through sliding doors, more space behind the last row.
What you’re paying the SUV premium for is the shape. That’s it. It looks like an SUV rather than a van, and for a lot of people that’s worth real money. Fine — but be honest that it’s what you’re buying, because it isn’t buying you space.
The one thing that puts a seven-seat SUV ahead is a capability the van doesn’t have. Serious towing is the obvious one. If you tow, the argument changes and the SUV earns its place. If you don’t, you’re paying more for less.
Small, medium or large
Small fits pretty much anyone if you’re an urban dweller. If you’re max three, small works. Keep in mind today’s small is yesterday’s medium and large.
Families with kids would probably aim for medium, just because you have things and you end up with a lot of driving: prams at first, later the sports and the beaches and hopefully weekends away and camping.
Large: most people with a large car don’t need it. People buy a Land Cruiser and spend ninety-five per cent of the time with one or two people in it, in a city. Of course, for the five per cent of the time you’re going hardcore camping, a large 4x4 works. It’s up to you what your split is. You define your own value.8
Which trim
Buy the base model
Higher-end models buy you numbers, speed and features that work better as marketing promises than as real value to a regular person.
Take the sound system. I love good audio — I build my own speakers. The base system in a modern car is already more than good enough. The upgrade costs thousands for maybe ten percent more, and you will not care after week two. Same story for most of the options list.
If you’re parking it on the street, not having a sunroof is sometimes a good thing. It’ll be a bit less hot, and it’s one less thing to break. So the budget model is often the one to have: the base EX5 is a lot of car for your money, and the size is decent — it’s not much smaller than the more expensive, bigger mid-size EVs like the Tesla Model Y.
The Model Y: my pick is the base Model Y. The value of the upgrades is minimal despite whatever the numbers and marketing promises. The Zeekr 7X: my pick of this is the entry level, or perhaps the long range. There are three quite different versions in terms of performance and price, but I think this is one of those examples where you just would be totally fine with the basics.
Every car page here names the variant to buy. That’s the one the price and the rating are about.
Anything under six seconds is stupid fast
Two seconds faster to 100. All-wheel drive. Four hundred kilowatts. Are you escaping marauders? Are you a rally driver? The school run doesn’t need it.
Anything under six seconds to 100 is stupid fast, and no, you will never ever use that speed. Unless you have driven a rally car and smacked your helmet hard enough on a roll bar, drifted hundreds of metres, cornered so hard the car is beyond two wheels, and have the mental ability to figure out what’s happening and how to get down safely without crashing into other cars.
I don’t give a shit about speed. I’ve rally driven, I’ve rolled things, I’ve almost died. Speed is fun. Speed is thrilling. But in this modern world there is absolutely no point, and anyone who says otherwise is fooling themselves — unless you’re on a racetrack or rally driving, in which case why the heck are you reading this? This is for sensible people buying a sensible car.
Floor the base Model Y, it’s so fast you don’t need more speed. It’s really fast. You want to drive track? Save the money, buy yourself some nice track days, a go-kart, fly to Italy, rent a nice manual car from Europe’s glory days.
When the step up earns it
For ninety-five per cent of people, the long-range battery is not worth it. The base model is fine. Look at a Tesla Model Y: once you reach the price range of a Zeekr 7X, even the cheaper range, the base models are just fine.
So when is the base model not worth it? You want more than five seats. Six will do, and that’s the upgrade from the Model Y to the Model Y L. You are paying substantially more, but in that price range there aren’t too many options, so it makes sense. But then you’re so close to a people-mover, consider that as well.
Why “luxury EV” is an oxymoron
“Luxury EV” is now an oxymoron. The battery and the motor changed the game so much that the very phrase doesn’t hold. The right word is money extraction machine. These Chinese mid-range EVs are killing it. You can buy some stupidly overpriced Chinese luxury EVs as well; don’t buy them either.
The iPhone and the handbag
In the past, you upgraded from a Toyota to a Lexus and you got a smoother engine, more leather, more luxe; it felt better, drove better. In an EV the only things that can make the experience more are range, quality of materials and speed. And when you look at a car like the Zeekr 7X, it delivers basically everything already.
It’s hard for older Australians to get that. Think iPhone. You get an iPhone Pro Max, you have the same as the billionaires. There is no better. Now with cars, the difference is even starker — not only is your expensive EV no better, often it’s worse and backwards. Ten years ago, you had a Porsche and people were impressed. Today, as Rhett put it: frankly, my dear, no one gives a damn.
Think handbags. You can buy a Coach or a Gucci or a Birkin for thousands of dollars. Name a single thing where they do better than a Patagonia bag. In fact you can probably name ten things where the more expensive one uses lesser-quality materials; the Patagonia’s straps will last longer. No one’s tested the Gucci for playing tug of war with an angry bear in the Canadian mountains, or whatever else Patagonia does.9
Name one thing it does better
Basically all the European ones which are more expensive fall short compared to these. So go and drive a fifty-seven thousand dollar Chinese EV or a Tesla Model Y, and name one thing this car does better than them. On the quality ladder the Zeekr pretty much delivers, unless you go all the way to a really expensive luxury car, and even then it’s not far off. Speed? That’s not something the Euros compete in anymore; at best they draw level.
A mid-size EV having rear-wheel steering is good to have, that’s definitely a nice feature. But what value is it adding? Certainly far short of the price gap between this and the Chinese EV competition.
Now if there was something to back it up — space-age technology — please, go for it. I am on the lookout for cars which genuinely deliver something exciting.10
Don’t waste your money on luxury EVs, it’s not a thing anymore.
›speed 250 kW 310 kW
KO: Watch any old American movie, Gone in 60 Seconds. With this car, we're firmly in the era of press cruise control and move sensibly at the speed limit.
›range 654 km 627 km*
KO: The Zeekr Long Range is 627 km WLTP, so close enough, and that's still a lot cheaper than the Macan EV.
*The 7X Long Range, $63,900.
›warranty 3 years 5 years
Both batteries: 8 years or 160,000 km.
›handling an SUV an SUV
KO: They all have a similar type of awesome brakes. … Handling in an SUV is just marketing bollocks. No matter how much you cut the corners of a box, the box is not designed or intended for handling. … If you want handling, drive a 1967 Ford Mustang with the V8.
Front brake discs: 350 mm on the Macan, 364 mm on the 7X.
›leather leather leather
KO: Leather is leather, yeah really, at this level.
›the badge +$71,900 –
KO: The value of racing was super high as a signal to show the quality. … In today's Porsche very little of that is happening anymore. Like, where is this battery coming from? … So today, to me, badges say old, left behind.
Underneath: PPE, the platform the Macan shares with the Audi Q6 e-tron.
Who makes it, and will they be here
Buy the car, not the history
A lot of people buy a reputation earned decades ago.
The badge that meant something in 1995 is not a claim about the car sitting in the showroom in 2026. Reputations are a trailing indicator — they’re built slowly, they decay slowly, and for a while a brand can coast on goodwill it is no longer earning. That gap is where a lot of money gets wasted.
It isn’t nationalism in either direction. You are not obliged to fund a company because it used to be good. You’re spending your own money, once every several years, on a thing you have to live with. Buy what is best today.
A warranty is a balance sheet
Will this company still exist in five years to honour the warranty? That one is real and almost nobody asks it. A seven-year warranty is a promise from a balance sheet, not from a car.
I’m not saying you only want to buy a car which has sales. If you are buying a true rarity, like a Ferrari F40, sales are different. For everything else, every car page here shows what it sells a month in Australia and where that sits in its class. Anything selling fewer than about fifty a month is a flag, once it has been on sale for three months or so. Before that, it’s just a new entry, and the page says so.
Charging, FBT, self-driving, towing
Charging
If you can charge at home, awesome. Plug into the wall and it’ll do.11 Go home, plug it in, never go to the pump.
Charging without a garage
Live in a townhouse or an apartment with no garage? It’s getting easier.
Strata. Australia is moving towards making charging in a strata complex almost a human right, so it’s getting much harder for a strata to say no. Cheap setups for apartment blocks are coming out too.12
Shopping centres. In any big city, shopping centres and plenty of other places are putting in fast chargers. They cost more than charging at home, but they work.
Kerbside. More city streets have kerbside chargers, but they’re few and far between. In the City of Sydney, where I live, there isn’t one within walking distance, not even within a kilometre and a half. And they sit in ordinary parking spots, so most of the time there’s a petrol car parked at the charger. I expect councils to fix that.
Where this should end up is what Germany, a growing number of other European cities and parts of China already do: a charger on every pole. If five houses on a street have EVs and nowhere to charge them, the council should put chargers on two poles, two cars each. That’s the fix, and I think we’ll get there in the next few years.
It’s a win for the grid too: parked cars charge, and can send power back. Ausgrid, AEMO and the regulators should be planning for it, with an Australian standard, instead of leaving it to small companies each putting in their own random chargers.
On the road, Australia is building out fast chargers, and I’m not really liking the rollout. It is a lot more expensive: many on-road chargers are charging ten to twenty times what people pay at home, even forgetting free solar. Still, there are plenty of chargers, and shopping malls and other destinations keep adding them.
In a Tesla, you plug in your car and it charges. That’s it. In every other car, you sign up to at least 5 apps, you have RFID cards, you plug in the charger, you unplug, the damn thing may or may not work. I would like the government to step in and mandate some simple things, like a basic credit-card tap to pay.13
The FBT exemption
If your employer offers a novated lease, an EV under the luxury car tax threshold is exempt from fringe benefits tax, and that is worth a lot. This site doesn’t cover the detail; novatedlease.guide does it well.
Under $75,000 the exemption continues for a while, so if you have a salary, consider a novated lease and save even more money. The key thing is a relatively steady job, say for a couple of years, so you can commit to a two-to-four-year novated lease.14
Let the car drive
With lots of driver experience, I don’t see the value of paying, say, $10K more to get an FSD-ready Tesla if I don’t need such a car. However, for older people this is a no-brainer if they are in the price range or above. Nothing beats self-driving for some people.
This is all assuming Tesla irons out the remaining kinks.
Towing
Most people reading this don’t tow, so it’s not very important, but towing drastically lowers range. If I had to tow, I’d probably buy a Model Y all-wheel drive: decent range and four powered wheels. A rear-wheel drive would do, but for peace of mind, for traction, I might get the all-wheel drive. Why a Model Y? Other EVs in the price range are fine, but this one has good range, and since you’re going to lose twenty to fifty per cent of it towing, you might as well start a bit high.
How to read the numbers on this site
The number over the line
Every page here shows what you’d pay against the cheapest car in the class I’d actually recommend. That number is the review.
There’s an unspoken expectation that because a company spent a lot of money building something, we should all be gentle about it. I don’t accept that. The money runs the other way: you’re the one spending, and it’s your money that has to be justified, not their feelings.
The correction is to go back to things you can actually check:
- What is it, and what does it do?
- How does it ride? Does it vibrate? Is it quiet?
- How far does it actually go?
- How well is it built — under the panels, not just where you can see?
- What does it cost to make, and what am I paying for beyond that?
- Will this company still exist in five years to honour the warranty?
What the rating means
| 1 | Terrible. |
| 2 | It passes as a car. |
| 3 | The great average. |
| 4 | A nice car, often cheaper or the same price as lower-rated ones. |
| 5 | The Holy Grail. We are not there yet. |
I ding every car for not having some kind of automotive smarts. Now some people don’t really care about it, but I do think these things are getting more and more important.
A 4 is the line on this site: those are the cars marked “I’d buy it”, and the cheapest of them at each size draws the value line on the front page.
Where a page says I’ve driven the car, I have.15
A rating has a date
When I mark a car down, I’m usually not saying it got worse. I’m saying the field moved.
Take the Denza D9. It’s about two years old. It was a good car then. Judged in a vacuum, as though no other car existed, it’s still a good car today. It’ll do the job of getting you from A to B, and the battery underneath it is proven.
But nobody buys a car in a vacuum. You buy it against everything else on sale that week, at that money. And by today’s standard, against today’s competition, it is no longer a good car. Both are true.
If a car’s value isn’t a property of the car but a relationship between the car and everything else at that price, then a rating has a date on it. Nothing about the car changed. The thing it’s measured against did.
It cuts the other way as well. A car that holds its rating for three years while the market moves under it is doing something impressive, and that’s worth more than a good launch review.
Reading the reviews
Car reviews sometimes over-recommend expensive cars, or don’t realise that good enough lands for most people. Reviewers drive hundreds of cars a year, including genuinely exotic ones. Sit someone in an expensive car on Monday and a sensible hatchback on Thursday and of course the hatchback disappoints. To be fair, some of the Australian reviewers are better at this. This guide is trying to think about it more holistically: what do you actually need?
You end up with the thing you fought against. Look at how Australian reviewers received the Model Y L — amazing, such value, the perfect family car. It’s an eighty-one thousand dollar vehicle. At some point “sensible family car” quietly came to mean sixty thousand drive-away, incomes didn’t go up at the same speed, and no one said anything.
Think of the Top Gear lads in their later years, unable to be satisfied by anything. Then think of what they were actually doing in the good episodes: driving cheap cars to interesting places and having the time of their lives. The fun was the journey and the people. Almost none of the great road trips were unlocked by spending hundreds of thousands of dollars. It was you and your mates, not the boot capacity.
Stuck on a word? The glossary has them, a line or two each.
- The base GX at $42k drive-away is too basic. A fair comparison to most of these $30k-plus EVs is the GXL, at $46k drive-away at a minimum, or actually the Atmos. Just think about all the features the Chinese offer out of the box.↩
- The XPeng L03, which is probably still a few months away, is generations ahead.↩
- The Geely EX5 Complete is a good car, at $45,489 drive-away in NSW.↩
- People will still buy them. People don’t have much money, and as these cars get cheaper and cheaper they’ll still make sense to buy. Not everyone can budget long term (“over five years I’ll save so much fuel”); sometimes you just have to buy at the price available today. You can go out right now and buy an eight-thousand-dollar car, and if you have some skills you’ll easily drive it for a number of years, especially if you’ve got a garage, can buy some parts, figure stuff out (AI will help) and do the basic servicing at home.↩
- Australia’s charging networks are going to get better: nicer, more pleasant places to charge, and more of them. You might feel the EV you buy today only has so much range, and the one you’d buy five years later will have so much more. I still think today’s 400-kilometre EV is going to hold its value five years from now.↩
- We don’t list ANCAP ratings, but most of our well-rated EVs have five stars. A few newer arrivals haven’t been tested here yet, the Atto 2 among them, so check the car you’re looking at.↩
- I have a friend with a small car and a Land Cruiser with diff lockers, a lift kit, the whole nine yards, and a trailer. It’s not getting much use at the moment, say five days a year on average. But hey, the dream is real.↩
- So I see that people attach value to products. But when you buy sunglasses made by a clothes designer for hundreds of dollars — gone are the days where Mr Gucci spent a lifetime perfecting the craft of sunglasses and has an amazing factory building state-of-the-art lenses. None of that is true. He’s buying a reasonably mid-range frame and lenses, nothing special, and you pay $250 extra for nothing.↩
- Say the new Tesla Roadster: hey, it flies, cool, buy it. But actually it’s going to be tiny and cramped, and sure it goes super fast, but it’s going to be pointlessly fast. So no, I can tell you up front: don’t buy it.↩
- At some point spend a few hundred dollars on a nicer charger on your wall: at home you probably don’t drink straight from the tap, you bought a glass. Don’t sweat the specs. A basic 7 kW will do most people; go for 11 if you want. The NSW government’s home charger page explains the types (a normal power point is “level 1”, a wall charger “level 2”) and its zero-interest loans that can cover one.↩
- For example, Alchemy Charge’s Strata Assist.↩
- Every goddamn thing in this country makes you tap and pay; EV chargers are the only thing where you make an account and use a stupid RFID card. And the most bollocks part: when you plug in, the car talks to the charger and gives up all its info — I’m this car, I have this battery, I have this charge. What more do they want to know? There is zero, absolutely zero reason for apps and RFID cards. The best RFID card is your debit card. We already use it everywhere, on Opal, on planes, everywhere but the stupid EV chargers.↩
- The 2026 Budget winds it back by the date a lease is committed to: until 31 March 2027, every EV under the threshold is exempt. From 1 April 2027 to 31 March 2029, a car of $75,000 or less still pays no FBT for the life of that lease, and one between $75,001 and the threshold gets a 25% discount. From 1 April 2029, it’s a 25% discount for all of them. It isn’t law yet; novatedlease.guide keeps track.↩
- I haven’t driven most of these cars. I’ve sat in them, at EV shows and the like, and there’s one in Sydney soon that I’ll be at.↩