This is the one car every salaried Australian should seriously consider. Buy it on a novated lease and it comes out really cheaper than pretty much any petrol car, and it’s a lot better than the low end of the petrol market. Buy the Dynamic. The MG 4 Urban is the value leader and a little cheaper, but I rate the Atto 2 higher: size matters to a lot of people, and the money is similar.
What you’re getting
A small SUV that’s genuinely roomy for its size. The Driven put a 195cm reviewer in the back seat comfortably, helped by the tall roofline, and CarExpert found the second row spacious with generous headroom and legroom.
On the road it’s a town car. Drive called the ride largely comfortable and soft, and carsales found the ride and handling better sorted than expected. EV Central and The Driven both describe the steering as light, and carsales adds that it gets vaguer above 50km/h.
CarExpert tested the 10–80% charge at 38 minutes, which matches what Drive and carsales found.
What the extra buys you
The Premium adds a bigger screen, power-adjustable heated and ventilated front seats, a glass roof, eight speakers, wireless phone charging and a 360 camera. The Driven is clear that the battery, motor and range don’t change, so none of it fixes the car’s weak points. Money matters at this price, and for more money there are potentially better EVs now.
Reviewers split on it. CarsGuide and CarExpert both point to the Dynamic as the one to have. EV Central says the Premium is worth it for the 17-inch wheels, though it also found the Dynamic’s seats less padded and called the Premium’s massage-like. The Driven calls the Dynamic’s case convincing and says the Premium is surrounded.
Those alternatives are the real question. Drive’s argument is that Leapmotor B10, Geely EX5 and Chery E5 give roughly 100km more range and faster charging for similar money. One commenter I’ve quoted says the same about the B10 and EX5, much better on almost every aspect for the same money. Any other car in the dearer bracket I’d call an upgrade, in specs and probably feel. The Geely EX5 Complete is a good car too.
Against the Toyota Corolla Cross hybrid
I drove the new Corolla Cross hybrid extensively. It’s a nice car, but it’s dated, a little cramped, with a smallish boot. It feels like a car made into a mini SUV, with the engine and transmission eating space you can feel from the seat. It’s designed on a really tight budget, and it feels dated after time in an EV.
Side by side, the EV feels technologically smarter and more able. The screens are bigger, the seats better, and the Chinese makers think more about this. The base GX is too basic: you need the GXL at least to compare fairly, and the Atto 2 comes with the features that Toyota charges extra for. Anyone looking at the GX should look at the Atto 2 Premium instead, because at a cheaper price you get a lot more.
For the Corolla Cross shopper the better car is the Atto 2, not the Atto 1. With kids, slightly taller is good, with more storage and easier car seats. If a Corolla Cross shopper can wait, the Xpeng L03 is a few months away and I’d call it generations ahead.
What’s wrong with it
Range and charging, first. Drive, carsales and CarExpert all lead with them. Carsales measured about 500km of mixed driving and put real range closer to 320km than the claimed 345km. Charging is slow, and Drive says rivals give roughly 100km more range for similar money. The Driven says the charging already looks dated under a year in.
Then the controls. CarExpert says nearly everything, climate included, lives in the touchscreen, and the seven centre-console buttons all feel the same, so finding hazards in a hurry is hard. Drive’s first drive says the same about heating and ventilation, yet its Ora 5 comparison praises the physical buttons and dials. The reviewers disagree.
Software. The Driven hit a built-in navigation server error during its week, and speed-limit assist showed an 80km/h sign on one side of the cluster while warning about 60km/h on the other. CarsGuide found the driver aids give sticky, artificial steering corrections on straight roads and had to switch them off on the highway.
Motorway manners. Drive reports wind penetration at middling speeds and a roar over 80km/h; The Driven notes more tyre and wind noise than newer or dearer EVs, and a motor that feels less muscular as speed rises. CarExpert calls the ride firm on the highway; CarsGuide says it wallows over rough bitumen through faster corners.
No spare wheel. Carsales, CarsGuide and CarExpert all note it, just a repair kit. One Whirlpool owner reported that the space-saver spare doesn’t fit in the boot anyway.
Single owner reports on Whirlpool add a loud air-conditioning compressor, DAB dropouts and a wind whistle at the driver’s window, and owners confirmed the Premium has no dashcam or sentry mode.
Living with it
Several Whirlpool owners reported using less energy than the rated figure. A r/AustralianEV commenter doing short commutes said overnight home charging covers it without public chargers, but that highway driving drains it faster than stated.
BYD’s one year of roadside assistance is short next to Leapmotor’s eight, which Drive points out. Nothing yet on how it holds up past a year. One commenter said BYD is investing in its dealer network and parts supply.
If you have a steady job, say for a couple of years, the FBT exemption on a two-to-four-year lease can cut the cost further.
Which one to buy
The Dynamic. Money matters at this price point, and the extra for the Premium buys cabin equipment, not a better car.
Verdict
It’s a good car and it sits a notch above the value leader for size. The range is short and the charging slow, so it suits a household that charges at home. On a lease it undercuts the petrol cars it replaces.