Tesla Model Y 2027

Tesla · 4.2/5 · BEV · 5 seats · 4,792mm, a medium car

good solid car, self driving potential, frequent updates

the pick: Premium RWD · $58,900

mid-size evs: +$16,910 over the Geely EX5 what's this?

FBT exempt — under the LCT threshold, worth thousands a year on a novated lease.

The Model Y is close to being my pick in mid-size. Someone sat down, worked out what a car needs to get you from A to B, did those things well and threw out the rest. That’s the toaster ideal, and the future-proofing of self-driving is the part I like most. The Geely EX5 is the cheaper way to do the same job, and it’s the class value leader. The Model Y is dearer than it, and if it were a bit cheaper it would be a top pick.

What you’re getting

A solid, basic family car with a big computer under it that Tesla keeps updating. That’s the bet: you’re buying something that gets better after you’ve paid.

The charging is the other reason. In a Tesla you plug in and it charges. Every other car means signing up to five apps and a pile of RFID cards, then hoping the charger works. Drive’s long-term tester agreed: three months in, the Supercharger network rarely failed and slotted straight into route planning.

CarExpert and Chasing Cars both say the updated car rides better and is quieter than the old one, and Chasing Cars found the cabin build much tighter. Drive’s tester came in an EV sceptic and left converted, praising smooth throttle, brakes and steering. CarExpert’s own take is that it ticks every box and has no soul. For a toaster, that’s fine.

Self-driving

I did three test drives with FSD, and every time it got something wrong. It turned onto the wrong side of the road. On Anzac Parade it drove onto the light rail tracks. It disengaged noisily when a truck overtook too close, for no reason I could see. It’s not ready for prime time: treat it like cruise control on a highway, alert, hands on the wheel, ready to take over.

Even so, the version on sale today already makes a daily trip easier, and I see it improving. It’s like smart cruise, which everyone who uses it loves: not robotic, but less work.

Who should pay for it? If you’re younger and don’t need it, I don’t see the value in paying extra for an FSD-ready Tesla. For older people it’s a no-brainer if they’re in the price range or above, and that goes for every 5-seater. Nothing beats self-driving for some people. That all assumes Tesla irons out the kinks.

Drive says not to buy the car for FSD, and the version 14.3.9 videos don’t agree with each other. Tesla FSD Test says it still fails roundabouts and parking. A Melbourne video says it handled multi-lane roundabouts without brake stabbing. One owner said FSD was the single biggest reason his family was glad to upgrade.

What the extra buys you

Against the EX5 you’re getting FSD potential, the charging network, and a car that keeps being updated. Those are real. The EX5 gives you the basics for far less, and it’s not much smaller than the Model Y.

The Model 3 is the closer comparison. It’s cheaper and I rate it higher: smaller, but otherwise much the same car.

What’s wrong with it

  • Everything’s on the screen. CarExpert and Drive both complain that the gear selector is in the touchscreen, which slows a three-point turn. Climate, mirrors and steering wheel position go through menus as well. There’s no Apple CarPlay or Android Auto.
  • The steering. Chasing Cars found it twitchy at the slightest input, even at highway speed.
  • No charging cable in the box, and a short vehicle warranty by Chasing Cars’ count.
  • A rear seat base that’s too flat for long legs (Chasing Cars), and a knees-up position for taller adults (CarExpert).
  • Regressions from the old car. One owner who upgraded from a 2022 car reported a smaller glovebox and basic summon gone.

Living with it

Take the Whirlpool owners’ thread with salt: it’s mostly earlier cars, and unhappy owners post more than happy ones. Its owners reported soft paint that chips (mudflaps and paint protection on the rear doors was the most repeated advice), Sentry Mode draining the battery, and front suspension links replaced under warranty. Phantom braking is the longest-running complaint, and some said it’s still there on recent software. On the good side, several said mobile service came to them fast.

The base car’s LFP battery can be charged to 100 per cent regularly, which Chasing Cars notes the Long Range’s pack can’t. That matters if you’re doing it daily.

Which one to buy

The base Model Y. The upgrades buy numbers, speed and features that work better as marketing than as anything a regular person feels. It’s so fast already that you don’t need more. If you want a track, spend the money on track days, a go-kart, or a trip to Italy to rent a nice manual.

One exception: towing. I’d lean to the all-wheel drive for the traction and peace of mind. A rear-wheel drive would do, but you lose a good chunk of range towing, so you may as well start high.

Verdict

It’s a good car, and the pick is the base one. It isn’t the value leader. What it adds over the EX5 is FSD potential, the charging network and the updates, so buy it if those matter to you.

## variants

variantpricerangeKO's note
Premium RWD ← the pick $58,900—
Long Range AWD $68,900—Buys you numbers, speed and features that work better as marketing promises than as real, tangible value to a regular person.
Performance $84,900—Floor the base Model Y: it's so fast you don't need more speed. Want a track? Save the money for track days, a go-kart, or a manual from Europe's glory days.

## sales

4,476 sold in September · 35,930 so far this year

Tesla sold 5,654 electric cars that month, 41,705 this year.

Australian deliveries, from The Driven's VFACTS and Electric Vehicle Council tables.

official site →

towing: 1,588 kg braked

approval on the federal register (ROVER) →

worth reading:

price last checked 2026-10-12.