The Atto 3 had a great update, but only the top trim got it. I’d consider the Premium: it’s a very good car, but it’s playing in a very crowded field now. The Atto 2 rates higher for much less, and the MG 4 Urban leads the class on value.
What you’re getting
The Atto 3 is getting long in the tooth. It launched a while back, and the update splits the range in two. The Premium is the only one on the new 800V platform, with a rear motor and a bigger battery. The Essential and Evo Dynamic are the old car with a new badge, and the base is old and tired.
The Premium is the one worth a look. WhichCar and CarExpert both put the 10-80% charge at 25 minutes. With no front motor it gets a front boot, and the tow rating goes up to 1,500 kg. CarExpert found the rear floor flat and the cabin roomy for the size. The 15.6-inch screen runs Google built-in, which one Whirlpool buyer gave as the reason they chose it over the Sealion 7.
What the extra buys you
The Atto 2 is the harder question. It’s much cheaper, I rate it higher, and I think every salaried buyer should seriously consider it. CarExpert’s drive of the Evo reached the same place: the Premium is the only real Evo, and the Atto 2 is the better buy.
What the Premium adds is rear-wheel drive, a bigger battery and faster charging. But at this price it’s close to cars I think are potentially better, the Zeekr X among them. The GAC Aion V is the cleaner comparison: same rating from me, and it costs less.
How the reviewers found it to drive
They don’t agree. Ludicrous Feed called the steering surprisingly tight for a Chinese EV and said rear drive ended the old car’s torque steer. CarExpert called the same steering heavy, numb and artificial, and the ride firm. Electrify This also found the ride firmer than the Geely EX5’s and the steering heavy. WhichCar liked the balance on a twisty road, but its preview drive was spoiled by over-inflated tyres.
What’s wrong with it
- The driver aids. The most repeated gripe. CarExpert, WhichCar, EV Central and Electrify This all found the driver monitoring too eager, and EV Central says you switch it off every time you start the car. CarExpert says the lane-keep tugs the wheel on narrow and off-camber roads and the ADAS settings are buried in menus.
- The controls. More has moved to the screen. The shifter is now a column stalk, and one Whirlpool poster called it and the combined indicator and wiper stalk cheap and unintuitive for a car this dear. Regen is woolly with no one-pedal mode (CarExpert, Ludicrous Feed, Electrify This).
- The rear charge port. Two reviewers disliked it, and a Whirlpool poster said it means taking the wrong bay at older Tesla chargers.
- No spare wheel, only a repair kit (CarExpert).
- Smaller things. Rear headroom under the sunroof is tight for a 5’10” adult (Beyond EV). The built-in dashcam the old car had is gone, according to Whirlpool posters, who don’t know whether it comes back.
Living with it
Too early to say. The Whirlpool owners have had their cars for days and no faults are reported yet. Two posters say there’s no towbar available yet. One poster, citing video tests, said the fast-charge speed falls away around half charge; that’s second-hand, not an owner’s log. Nothing yet on servicing.
BYD is solid but a bit old now, and it’s still behind in self-driving.
Which one to buy
The Premium, because it’s the only one with the new platform. The base and mid trims are the old car.
Verdict
A very good car in a crowded field, and only the Premium has the update. Look at the Atto 2 and the Aion V before you sign.