Buy the base Essential. BYD has it on sale at the moment, and that’s what makes it a no-brainer. It’s a great second city car: short trips, a charger at home, another car in the driveway for everything else.
The catch is range, and it won’t work for everyone. If you do road trips, sadly this isn’t the car for you. If they’re rare, rent something for the big ones with the money you’ve saved.
What you’re getting
A four-seat hatch just under four metres long, and Drive and CarsGuide both call it Australia’s cheapest new EV. Reviewers keep landing on the same things: it’s easy to park, it’s quiet for the money, and the ride is better than the size suggests. The Right Car? said the ride and steering feel like a modern Polo or better. NRMA found the rear seat roomy for two average-sized adults, and CarExpert and CarsGuide both liked the deep boot floor.
Four seats, not five. CarExpert points out that rules out three kids across the back.
What it gives up
The Essential’s claimed range is 220 km, against 310 km for the Premium. Nobody I’ve read measured the Essential, but The Right Car? put the Premium nearer 250 to 260 km in real driving, so expect the base to fall short of its number too. A Reddit thread asked whether the base is worth it with no home charging. None of those posters owned one, but about eight of twelve said the short range is what makes it hard without a wall socket, and one expected to want a charge after about 150 km of urban driving. That matches what I’d say: get the base if you can charge at home.
CarExpert, Drive and The Right Car? all tell you to step up to the Premium. It does add a lot: a bigger battery, more power, a surround-view camera, heated seats. But I think we’re looking for a cheap EV, and you can live with the range of the base. If you want the extra range and kit, the Premium is an excellent second car too.
The MG 4 Urban leads the small-EV class. It’s a bigger five-seater and much dearer, so you’re paying for size this car never claimed to have.
What’s wrong with it
The nagging comes first, because you’d feel it every drive. The driver monitor and lane-keep assist fire constantly and, per CarsGuide, turn themselves back on at every restart. Drive says the driver monitor can’t be switched off at all, and NRMA caught it flagging a yawn and a pair of sunglasses.
Next, the touchscreen runs the climate. CarExpert noted that fan speed and seat heat are buried in menus, and the temperature is a 1 to 17 scale rather than degrees.
Then missing gear. No blind-spot monitoring or rear cross-traffic alert (Drive, WhichCar), no rear wiper, and a sound system four reviewers called poor or terrible. CarsGuide also lists no heat pump, so winter heating drags range down, and no liquid cooling for the battery.
Inside, there are hard plastics where your arm rests (CarExpert, NRMA), and CarsGuide found the front seats short on back and thigh support. The Driven was the outlier, finding the materials closer to the dearer Dolphin than a cheap city car, so how much this bothers you is a matter of taste. CarsGuide also reported nervous steering when pushed at speed, and NRMA called the suspension soft with the body slow to settle. Fine for a city car.
Living with it
The Right Car? found the gear selector, a roller you push up for reverse and down for drive, takes a day to get used to. One owner who runs a Premium alongside a Sealion 7 told NRMA they got around 300 to 310 km in practice. That’s one owner a month in, and The Right Car? and The Driven measured less. Nothing yet on how any of it holds up past the first year.
Verdict
The Essential, if you drive short and charge at home. Skip it if road trips are part of your life.