I haven’t rated the i5 yet. It’s a big, heavy BMW sedan, or wagon in the Touring, and the sources like how it drives. My test for a European EV is whether it does one thing better than a Chinese EV or a Tesla Model Y. Speed doesn’t count, because the Europeans only draw level there now.
What you’re getting
The eDrive40 is the single-motor rear-drive car; the M60 xDrive adds a second motor and all-wheel drive. CarExpert and EV Central both say the ride and handling hide the weight, which is close to two and a half tonnes in the M60. EV Central says it’s quiet enough that you think you’re going slower than you are.
The exception I’d allow is a car that delivers something genuinely different, like four-wheel steering. The i5 has that. CarExpert lists rear-wheel steering as standard on the eDrive40 and Integral Active Steering in the M60 Touring’s standard suspension package, and says it makes a car over five metres long easy to park.
Charging time is 30 minutes for 10-80% in CarExpert’s Touring test. CarExpert also says the Touring’s cargo packaging matches the petrol 5 Series Touring.
What’s wrong with it
Range, first. EV Central says the battery is too small for the car: real-world use that means it struggles to see 400km between charges. CarExpert measured the Touring closer to BMW’s own claim, so the two outlets disagree. EV Central also notes there’s no spare tyre, so a flat likely means a tow truck, and reports an occasional driveline shudder when you ask for a lot of throttle from a low state of charge.
Then the software. CarExpert says the climate controls live on the touchscreen, and EV Central says even brake regeneration is buried in menus. CarExpert’s eDrive40 test found wireless CarPlay dropping out under toll booths, and glossy black trim that gets grubby fast. CarExpert’s Touring test found the brake pedal doesn’t match the acceleration.
An owner in Drive’s 2023 eDrive40 review lost both displays twice before they rebooted themselves. The same owner missed a front boot and found the rear transmission tunnel pointless on an EV. The owner was happy overall, and said BMW and the insurer handled a minor rear-end incident and a replacement Iconic Glow smoothly.
Living with it
The Drive owner found city fast charging fantastic and a Melbourne-Sydney return trip diabolical, with broken chargers and speeds well under advertised. That’s one owner’s trip, but it fits the range concern above.
Before I rate it
- Is rear steering enough to count as the exception, or does it only make a big car easier to park?
- What does the eDrive40 do that a Tesla Model Y L doesn’t, now that it’s the value leader in this class?
- BMW is the one European maker taking the Chinese head on. Does the i5 show it can compete on price?