It’s a good car and a hard sell. If you ever wanted a fancy Euro car, this is it, but I wouldn’t buy it at that price. Against the Geely EX5 it costs far more than taste can justify, and the Tesla Model 3 is rated higher and is much cheaper. The case for it is the badge, the history, and the childhood dream of owning a German luxury car. Those are real reasons. Just know that’s what you’re paying for.
What you’re getting
BMW’s first car on its new Neue Klasse platform, and I’d call it the high watermark of the European car industry right now. It’s the last stand for the Germans against the Chinese: either they can still go toe to toe, or BMW has redrawn the battlefield. It’s not the nicest looking, being an SUV, but it passes the “I’m not going to get embarrassed” test. Nobody laughs at you for buying it.
It’s no driver’s car in the old sense. One of my favourite cars ever was an old 5 Series with a manual gearbox, and this has nothing to do with that. No driving feel, no fake gear shifts.
On the road, CarExpert says it steers with real road feel, rides firm without a hard edge and keeps tyre roar down on coarse chip. Charging is quick on the 50 xDrive: Drive quotes 10 to 80 per cent in 21 minutes and Chasing Cars measured the same. Chasing Cars saw about 600km on the highway from that car. The rear seat is roomy with a flat floor, and CarsGuide liked the hard, wipe-clean plastic on the front seatbacks for kids’ boots. Warranty is five years on the car and eight on the battery.
What the extra buys you
Not as much as it asks. The Geely EX5 is the value leader in this class, and the base one is a lot of car. The Model 3 is rated higher again. What the BMW adds is the badge, the finish and the way it feels to be in. That’s a luxury premium, and a big one.
Against the Xpeng X9, the Model Y Performance and the Zeekr 7X
For the same money an Xpeng X9 gives you a ton more car. For less, a Model Y Performance (made in Germany, as it happens) is a faster option, and a Zeekr 7X Performance from China is way faster still. But sometimes you gotta go German.
Personally I’d go Tesla or Zeekr, because both bundle in more. If you want the old-school German luxury feel, the Zeekr delivers more of it than the base iX3, in spades. The Zeekr 7X is also a good car, so get the value add.
What’s wrong with it
Ranked by what you’d notice every week.
Screens over buttons. Drive, CarExpert and Chasing Cars all flag it. There’s no dial and almost no switches. Climate and drive modes live in the touchscreen, and regen levels take several presses. CarExpert also notes there’s no instrument cluster, so the map only shows on the centre screen.
The ride on big wheels. Drive found the 22-inch wheels firm and easily unsettled, and says to stay on the standard 20s. CarsGuide agrees the 22s aren’t worth it. CarsGuide also called the steering light and a bit wishy-washy on rough roads, and Chasing Cars said the standard tyres lack wet grip.
Cheap touches. Hard, scratchy plastic on the dash top and lower door cards, which gave Chasing Cars a few rattles. CarExpert found unlined door pockets that clatter and no rear map pockets. The pop-out door handles felt clunky to Chasing Cars.
Missing kit. No ventilated seats, which CarExpert points out the petrol X3 has. No spare wheel.
Driver aids. Drive’s adaptive regen braked hard for a pedestrian standing on the footpath. CarExpert says the assisted driving doesn’t cancel on braking, so it accelerates back to the set speed if you pull off the highway with it on.
Which one to buy
The 40. The 50 xDrive isn’t worth the urge to upgrade, because the 40 delivers 99 per cent of the car and all the extra money buys is speed. If you really want speed, get the Model Y Performance for less. CarExpert agrees on the 40 and adds that it slips under the luxury car tax line.
That matters right now. The 40 squeezes in under the tax, so the FBT benefit is on, but only if it’s delivered before 1 April 2027. Deliveries are already approaching April, so anyone chasing that has either ordered or is risking the cutoff. If you’re going to buy one, order now. But FBT isn’t the whole case. Plenty of BMW buyers don’t care about it, and it’s a good car without it.
Verdict
A good car, and too expensive. If two cars are about the same size and rated the same, there’s no reason to pay this much extra for the one with the badge. If the badge is the point, buy the 40 and don’t touch the options list.