The D9 is fine as a car and poor as a buy. The Xpeng X9 costs about the same, I rate it far higher, and it’s the better car in the ways you’d notice. Denza is offering individuals incentives on the D9, which tells you it knows. If you’re set on the D9, the front-wheel drive is the one to have.
What you’re getting
A very big, very tall seven-seater with a Blade battery I trust, and 30 minutes for a 10–80% charge. If you imagine there’s no other car in the world, it does the job of getting from A to B.
The Beep liked the second row: ventilation, massage, power leg rests, and a fridge between the seats. It also found the cabin quiet and the ride composed, and I haven’t got a note of my own on noise or bumps. I did find it drives more like a van than a car, a toaster on wheels. The Kia Carnival drove a little better, and the Carnival is my bar for a great people mover.
What the extra buys you
It costs a lot more than the Tesla Model Y L, the value leader here, and the extra size doesn’t buy you a usable boot: the D9’s is too small too. The Model Y L has the same problem behind its third row. Of the two, the D9 is the one asking for a lot more money.
Against the Xpeng X9
The worth of a car is defined by its competition, and the X9 has a few things that basically kill the D9.
- Much better technology at the same price. The software is way better.
- The third row folds flat, which gives you a lot more usable space. On the D9 it doesn’t.
- Rear-wheel steering, which is awesome for city use. The D9 doesn’t have it.
- Charging. The X9 is 800V and charges a lot faster. Australia doesn’t have much 800V infrastructure yet, but a lot is coming. So why buy yesterday’s technology when today’s is available at the same price?
The X9 has hardware controls where the D9 has an overdone panel in the second row. Its lane keep and cruise control are better, and it has parking assist, which the D9 lacks. For now the X9 is my pick in this class. It’s expensive, but the D9 is no cheaper in any way that counts.
What’s wrong with it
They over-indexed on making it feel luxe. The seats are gigantically thick. I think they could have shrunk them 20–30% with no loss of comfort. Space is the point of a giant car, and the seats sucked it up. There’s nowhere for an executive’s briefcase, and the boot is too small. The Beep also noted a shallower load area when everyone is aboard.
The third row doesn’t fold into the floor. That isn’t a BEV-first design. I think the platform was made to take a hybrid engine as well, so there’s too much space taken up by those constraints, with no tank to justify it. Two owners in a Singapore Facebook group said you have to shift the second row forward by hand before the third row will drop. Those owners are X9 buyers explaining why they chose it, so read that as one side. The Beep also said the middle seats don’t slide, so reaching the third row takes a squeeze.
The screen that shows the cars around you is flat-out wrong. Cars shimmer in and out of view, cars that are right there don’t appear, or pop up at the last minute. It’s dangerous, and I don’t see how it passed testing. The seat controls sit on a slightly unresponsive screen too, and I’d take a physical button over it. Electric seats are a good idea, and the massage is nice, but it’s two steps forward and one back.
It’s shaped like a brick, and that means poor highway efficiency. The Beep logged body roll, wallowing when hurried, and a kerb weight near 2.8 tonnes. Loaded with people and stuff, I can see it suffering on efficiency.
Two owners in that group called its height a dealbreaker for low car parks. Check the places you park.
Which one to buy
The FWD, which I drove, twice. I’ve read the all-wheel drive’s adaptive suspension isn’t a real improvement either. It feels like a feature that’s there to pad the equipment list, and I don’t think Denza optimised it for this car.
Verdict
The D9 comes from old-school box-seats-engine thinking, and Denza needs to look at how Xpeng, Nio and Xiaomi start from the space they have and make it useful. BYD’s own chairman has said they’re a couple of years behind, and it shows. Buy the X9.