Don’t buy this. It’s a car and it works, but there are plenty of cheaper, better options, and nothing here that justifies the money. If you want a Mustang, buy an old one.
What you’re getting
A heavy, first-generation Ford EV that isn’t fun to drive and has nothing to do with the glory days of the Mustang. The name is nostalgia used to sell you a mid-size SUV. I love stick shifts and old Mustangs, and I’d love an EV version of one. This isn’t it.
Ford’s own CEO says Ford is way behind the Chinese on EVs. On The Verge’s Decoder podcast he described the Mach-E’s wiring loom as 70 lb heavier than a Model Y’s. The host leases one, and he told her to wait for Ford’s next platform in 2027. That’s the maker admitting this is old engineering.
It isn’t terrible. Henry Man’s review is the one I’d point you to for why it works as a car: it drives well, the one-pedal driving is good, and the driver aids stay out of your way. CarExpert says the same about the safety gear, and found the steering direct, with feedback few electric SUVs match. WhichCar’s long-term car had no squeaks or rattles after thousands of kilometres, and a real range around 550 km with the air-con on.
What the extra buys you
Nothing I can find. The Geely EX5 is the value leader in this class, I rate it well, and it costs much less. The Tesla Model 3 is also much cheaper and I rate it far higher.
Henry Man says the Mach-E costs noticeably more than its key rivals and charges slower. His Premium took about 39 minutes from 20 to 80%. CarExpert clocked the Select at 32 minutes for 10 to 80%. The Kia EV6 GT and the Tesla Model Y both charge much faster, he says.
What’s wrong with it
- The ride. CarExpert calls the Select’s ride too firm and unpleasant: it picks up road edges and tosses heads around on dips and driveways. Henry Man found the same, stiffest on the GT. WhichCar blamed part of it on tyre pressures set too high at delivery.
- The software. Henry Man found noticeable lag and audio stuttering. WhichCar’s SYNC4 froze or failed to boot, and drive modes need the touchscreen.
- The glass roof has no sunshade. CarExpert, Henry Man and WhichCar all flag it. WhichCar’s black vinyl seats made the cabin heat up badly in summer.
- Driver aids misread things. CarExpert’s car misread digital motorway signs in Sydney, reading 110 as 70 or 90. WhichCar had phantom braking and system dropouts in dust, rain and bright sun.
- Small stuff. Rear doors have electronic handles with nothing to pull. The kick-to-open boot is unreliable. The bottle won’t fit in the door pocket because of the speakers. Servicing is every 12 months or 15,000 km, short next to some rivals, says CarExpert.
Living with it
Rear space is fine. CarExpert fits a 182 cm adult behind their own driving position, and Henry Man says legroom and headroom are good, though the high floor leaves your knees perched. The frunk is shallow, and there’s no spare wheel, only a repair kit.
Warranty is five years, with eight years or 160,000 km on the battery. Nothing in what I’ve read says how it holds up past a year or two.
Ford’s future is a separate question. I don’t see much hope for them beyond fancy words, and the US ban on Chinese EVs is what’s buying them time. Their next EV platform is due in 2027.
Verdict
It’s not terrible, but it’s a sad take on a sad car, and there’s nothing to be gained by buying it over the cheaper options. Skip it.