It’s a great car, but the BYD Atto 2 gives you more for less. That’s the short version. The MG 4 is also a bit expensive for what it is, and I wonder if it’s being replaced soon.
What you’re getting
A rear-drive small hatch that drives well. CarExpert found the ride smooth, the body control good over speed humps and the steering nicely weighted, and the cabin quiet on coarse roads. The updated car has physical buttons for climate and volume again, which fixes the old touchscreen-for-everything complaint. CarsGuide and CarExpert both put a 10–80% charge at 25 minutes.
The Essence 64 is the one most people will look at. The XPower is the fast one: if you want speed, why not.
What the extra buys you
The cheaper MG 4 Urban is the value leader in this class, and the Atto 2 is rated higher than this car. Both undercut it. The case for the MG 4 is the maker: I have faith in MG to be around long term in Australia. That’s a thin reason to pay more when the Atto 2 has more for less.
What’s wrong with it
The back seat comes first. CarExpert’s six-foot tester had his knees against the seatbacks, and CarsGuide’s 168cm driver found legroom tight behind him. There are no rear air vents and no centre armrest, and CarExpert adds no map pockets or rear lights. There’s no spare wheel, only a repair kit.
Then the software. CarsGuide’s week with the car had CarPlay refusing to reconnect on its own. CarExpert’s test car had buttons already broken at 22km, and it says there are no over-the-air updates. Service intervals have also been cut to every 12 months or 25,000km.
Owners add a few more. On Whirlpool, several report the emergency braking firing on nothing, at intersections and for parked cars. An official bulletin and dealer patch toned it down, though one owner reported a false stop for pedestrians on a traffic island in December 2025. Several also report the iSmart app timing out and looping on login. One owner reported dealers won’t apply firmware updates unless you report a fault, so ask and cite the bulletin.
Living with it
Owners say it’s cheap to run at home. Several on Whirlpool report charging at a few dollars per 100km on solar or off-peak, and one blogger, James Cridland, found it quiet and easy to charge from rooftop solar. He also found cruise control and lane assist could get confused and brake or tug the wheel. Public fast charging cost more: one Whirlpool owner said it ran dearer per 100km than an old diesel Golf. AC charging tops out at 6.6kW, which CarExpert flags against rivals that take more.
No heat pump, according to several owners, which costs efficiency on short winter trips. Several owners also report steep depreciation after the repeated price cuts.
Verdict
It’s a great car. It just isn’t the value leader, and the Atto 2 has more for less.