It’s a nice, decent car, and a good basic Corolla replacement. It’s also nowhere near the value leader in small EVs. The MG 4 Urban and the BYD Atto 2 both cost far less, and I rate both higher.
What you’re getting
A small SUV on the same rear-drive platform as the MG 4 hatch. The ride is the best thing about it. CarExpert calls the suspension compliant without being floppy, CarSauce says it settles quickly after big bumps, and Drive found the chassis agile for an SUV. CarsGuide says it’s a big step up from earlier MGs for comfort. The cabin is a step up too: Drive and CarExpert both note physical switches for climate and volume below the touchscreen, and CarExpert says it’s the nicest cabin in MG’s range.
Nobody buys a car like this for driving feel, and there’s not much more to say. It does the suburban job without fuss.
What’s wrong with it
The accelerator lag. I didn’t like it, and I don’t know if MG has fixed it since. Drive noticed the same lag between pedal and motor.
Power is the weak point of the drive. Drive says it tapers under load, and CarSauce says it fades above 80 km/h. CarSauce also hit a serious one: on a moderate hill at 58% battery the car was held to 45 km/h with the pedal floored. Drive saw output drop mid-climb once and not on a repeat run. MG lifted the motor in the top grade in July 2026, and the reviews of that grade pre-date it, so nobody has tested whether the update fixes this.
The software is the next problem. CarSauce had a laggy screen, CarPlay dropping out, and a crash when it adjusted brightness. Drive tested a different car that didn’t do it, and suspected build variance. Both Drive and CarSauce found the speed-sign reader invents limits and beeps about them, and CarSauce found the driver-monitoring camera nagging. CarSauce also found a loose driver’s seat that wobbled and squeaked when shaken.
Smaller things a family would feel: Drive measured the payload as tight, enough that five adults would use it up before any luggage. The tow rating is small. AC charging is slow. There’s no spare, only a repair kit.
Living with it
Drive tested the cheaper 49 kWh car and got real-world consumption close to MG’s claim. The 62 kWh car in its Excite grade beat the claim in mixed driving. CarExpert’s 62 test came in over its claim on a highway-heavy run. Range is fine for a small SUV and nothing special; CarsGuide points out the Kona Electric beat it from a similar battery five years ago.
CarExpert priced seven years of servicing and found it cheaper than the Kona’s. One owner in the web summary reported frustration with dealer support over a technical defect, but that’s one voice.
What the extra buys you
Against the leader, not much. The S5 rides well and the cabin is better than earlier MGs, and that’s real. But the MG 4 Urban and the Atto 2 do the small-car job for far less, and both are rated above this one.
Rivals in the next class up also push back. CarsGuide says the top Essence was creeping toward the Kia EV3’s price, and CarExpert thought the S5 “a bit much” for how small it is. The July 2026 update left the Essence 62 at the same price with more power, so that complaint softened a little, but not the one about being a smallish SUV.
On MG as a company, I have faith they’ll be around long term in Australia, and they’ve gone from bad engines to good EVs on nice platforms. That’s a reason to trust the badge. It doesn’t make the S5 a good buy against cheaper cars.
Verdict
A decent, comfortable, no-fuss car. But the cheaper options rate higher with me, so look at them first.