The Scenic is a pleasant, well-made small SUV that costs far more than the car that leads its class, the MG 4 Urban, and it’s rated below it. If you’re set on one, go long range. For most buyers the cheaper cars do the same job.
What you’re getting
A flat rear floor, a back seat adults can sit in for hours, and a portrait touchscreen that Drive called class-leading for speed. CarExpert and The Driven both liked that Renault kept physical climate buttons. The driver-assist systems are tuned to stay quiet: Drive, CarExpert and Chasing Cars all found them unobtrusive, and you can switch off what you don’t want. CarsGuide found it quiet and refined, and its fixed-price servicing is cheap next to the Kia EV5 and BYD Sealion 7, according to CarExpert.
The long range battery is the one that makes sense. CarsGuide logs 37 minutes for 10 to 80 per cent, and the 625km claim sits well above most small rivals. Chasing Cars got about 518km in mixed driving, so plan on that.
What the extra buys you
Not much you’d feel every week. The Scenic is a bigger car than most of its class and the cabin is better finished than the cheap end, but the class leader does the job for far less. The Atto 2 and the Geely EX2 are also much cheaper, and I rate the Atto 2 higher. Carsales called it an appealing heart buy and a hard head buy, which is fair.
What’s wrong with it
- Brakes. CarExpert called the pedal spongy with a vague bite point, its biggest complaint, and Drive found the bite inconsistent. It comes from blending regen with the friction brakes.
- Warranty. Five years and 100,000km on the car, which CarsGuide says is well off the market pace. The battery is eight years and 160,000km, which matches.
- Steering and ride. The rack is very quick. CarExpert said it was twitchy at first and then intuitive, and Drive thought it too sharp. The ride splits the reviewers: CarExpert found the 20-inch wheels bobbly on rough roads, Chasing Cars and Drive found it smooth.
- Practical gaps. No spare wheel, only a repair kit. No frunk. Chasing Cars found the boot shorter and deeper than it sounds, with a lip to lift over.
- Front-wheel drive only. The Driven called it an odd omission.
Chasing Cars also saw the test car lose charge overnight, going from 15 per cent to 12.
Living with it
Nothing yet on how it holds up past the first year. Renault sold fewer cars here last year than in any of the previous 14, according to CarExpert, and carsales flagged the dealer network and the warranty cap as ownership questions. I think Renault is dead, but it will linger on because of the EU. That’s a reason to be careful about long-term support.
Verdict
It’s a good car priced as if the badge matters. If you want the Scenic, go long range. If you just want a sensible small EV, the MG 4 Urban does the job for far less.