I haven’t rated the Smart #3 yet. It’s a small coupe-SUV that the sources like for ride, space and looks, and fault for software. The class has a cheaper value leader in the MG 4 Urban, so this one has to show what it does that the MG doesn’t.
What you’re getting
It shares its platform with the Volvo EX30, and Smart is a Mercedes and Geely joint venture. CarExpert found a lot of cabin space for the size, a stretched wheelbase that helps rear legroom, and a ride that smooths out bad Australian roads while staying composed. Sound deadening is good. Heated, power-adjustable front seats come even on the base Pro+.
Carsales liked the nimble feel, the tight turning circle and the big door bins. Rear legroom is generous. CarsGuide found the Brabus grips and handles well, though it called the steering inconsistent when loaded up at speed.
What’s wrong with it
The software, first. CarExpert and carsales both say too much is buried in the touchscreen, including mirror adjustment and climate. CarExpert’s test cars had voice control that didn’t work well and a navigation app stuck in China.
The driver aids are the next complaint. Carsales found the lane-keep reacts to old lane markings and tar lines until you switch it off. It also found speed-sign recognition picks up advisory signs and nags. One Whirlpool owner thread says the settings don’t stay off after a restart, though software 1.5.0 made them easier to reach.
Owners also report the built-in SIM is capped at 1GB a month. Once it’s gone, online navigation and apps stop until the next month.
The fixed glass roof is the other one. CarsGuide found the Brabus almost unbearable in hot sun with no sunblock. Whirlpool owners split: some manage, others fitted shades or foil boards. CarExpert called the interior materials hit and miss, with a lot of plastic on the doors, and the boot floor doesn’t fold flat.
Living with it
CarExpert logged a real-world efficiency result better than Smart’s claim. CarsGuide, on a long highway run with the climate working against the roof heat, got worse than claimed. Both are single tests.
Service is through LSH Auto, with dealers on the eastern seaboard. CarExpert flags that as a risk for buyers elsewhere. On the company, I rate Smart low. Daimler designs and China engineers, and I can’t see what Daimler adds beyond its dealer network. Nothing yet on how the car holds up past the first year or two.
Before I rate it
- Is the touchscreen livable day to day, or do the mirror and climate menus wear thin?
- Does the glass roof make summer a problem without a fix?
- What does a buyer get from this that the MG 4 Urban doesn’t?
- Is the dealer footprint enough to back a car you’d keep for years?